Since its inception on July 4, 1999, despite many applications and much web searching (so far several thousand sites have been reviewed), this prize
has only been awarded fifteen times (three awards were withdrawn for failure to display the award graphic, and two sites have left the internet):
Scars & Roses by Janet I. Buck - 1999
RMC, Duntroon by Harvey Shore - 2000 - No longer on the internet
The Chronicles of Furthermore by Skip Boyer - 2001
The Singing Voice by Mark D. Williams - 2001 - No longer on the internet
Cowboy Poetry by Rod Nichols (1942-2007) - 2002
Totems by Elizabeth Fuller - 2003
Cloud9 -- The Journeys by Ravi Menon - 2003 - No longer on the internet
The Magic Words by Nicole S. Porter - 2003 - No longer on the internet
Joe Kohl: Cartoonist/Illustrator - 12/5/04
Wet Dreams Poetry by Kathleen Opalinski - 9/14/05
Rowena's Page by S. D. Youngren - 2/23/07
Aces Don't Bluff by Joel Goulet - 6/4/07